With the great day of candy acquisition approaching, I'm genuinely begging you all to stop driving to the "nice" neighborhoods to trick-or-treat if at all possible.
I've lived in three different neighborhoods in my city. All were perfectly safe, walkable, and had a decent mix of families and people of all ages. None have had any trick-or-treaters in years. Because everybody drives to one of three wealthier neighborhoods across town.
We now live on the outskirts of one of those neighborhoods, so we get to witness the other side of this from 2 blocks away. And I've got a few gripes.
- The traffic is ridiculous.
Every road is packed with cars, both from across town and from smaller communities outside the city. And probably half the people out there aren't even getting out of their cars. They're just slowly cruising the streets while their kids hop out to hit houses. It gets so congested that it's just straight up unsafe.
- You're screwing over your own neighbors.
This is my biggest gripe. At every house we've lived in, we've decorated, bought candy, and gotten maybe one or two knocks all night. My wife loves holidays, and it genuinely guts her every year.
And I know we're not the only ones. There are people in your neighborhood who would love to hand out candy, see the kids in costumes, and participate in Halloween. But after a few years of nobody showing up, why would they keep bothering? Then fewer people decorate, fewer people buy candy, and the neighborhood becomes even less appealing the next year. It's a self-fulfilling prophecy.
- The candy jackpot is mostly a myth.
The whole "go to the rich neighborhood for full-sized candy bars" thing is overblown. I can think of maybe one house in our town that does it, and they're out by 6 p.m. anyway. After that, you're getting the same miniature candy you could've gotten anywhere else.
- It's gotten so bad that some neighborhoods are doing their own pre-trick-or-treating.
At least around here, some of the popular neighborhoods have started doing early Halloween activities just for their own kids because they know the rest of the city will show up an hour later.
You can call that exclusionary if you want, and I wouldn't necessarily disagree. But it's pretty sad that a neighborhood feels like it has to carve out a private window for its own children just to enjoy Halloween before the crowds arrive.
Halloween isn't a "rich-neighborhood"-exclusive holiday. Odds are good that if this stopped happening, your neighborhood might just be worth trick-or-treating in, too.
Sure, your kids might come home with a few more off-brand Jolly Ranchers and Tootsie Rolls instead of Snickers and Sour Patch Kids. But do we really think they care that much? They're little kids in costumes getting free candy from their neighbors, that's the whole point.
It might take a couple of years to turn things around. Neighborhoods that haven't seen trick-or-treaters in a decade aren't going to magically bounce back overnight. Maybe organize a block party or get a few neighbors together to decorate? I don't know.
Caveat: I'm talking about a solidly suburban city of about 100,000 people, where perfectly walkable neighborhoods are being bypassed for a handful of popular destinations. If you live somewhere genuinely unsafe or so spread out that walking door-to-door isn't practical, obviously that's a different story. But when 20,000 kids descend on a neighborhood of roughly 300 homes, maybe we've collectively lost the plot a little.