My wife and I have been together for over 10 years, and one of the biggest recurring arguments in our marriage involves my dad.
For context, my dad is a genuinely good person. He's been incredibly supportive of us, has helped us financially over the years, and is a fantastic grandfather to our two young kids. He's always been there for us.
However, he has a habit of making stupid, sometimes inappropriate jokes, especially when he has an audience. He's been like this my entire life. He's not intentionally cruel or malicious, but he sometimes says things without thinking about how they might affect other people. When called out, he typically brushes it off with "I'm just joking."
My wife and dad have had a weird relationship since 2017, when they both had a few drinks at a family dinner and he started lecturing her about how we needed to have children. This was before we'd even seriously discussed having kids ourselves. Turns out she was internally conflicted at them (this is whole separate issue that has been resolved since). She understandably snapped at him, and there's been underlying tension ever since.
There have been other weird incidents over the years. Last Christmas, for example, my dad was telling a story about selling real estate to people he described as "former criminals with lots of tattoos". He then gestured toward my wife, who has a lot of tattoos, and said, "Sorry, Jessie." Just a completely unnecessary comment that he apparently thought was funny. He tries to be funny when he has an audience. It's always been like this.
Most recently, we visited my parents with our two kids (almost 5 and 11 months). We've been exhausted dealing with the kids lately and asked my parents if they'd be willing to watch them while we went out to dinner.
My dad, sitting with my brother watching baseball, jokingly responded, "Yeah, I guess I'll suck it up and watch him." I know that he said this because my brother was there too, and he'd never say that if he wasn't there.
I knew immediately he was joking, but it bothered me because I've specifically told him before that I don't want him making jokes involving the kids. We ended up taking the baby with us to dinner.
My wife was really upset afterward and wanted me to address the comment with him. Here's where the real issue comes in.
For years, I defended my dad when these things happened. I'd say things like "That's just how he is" or "He didn't mean anything by it." Having grown up with him, I've become so accustomed to his personality that most of these comments barely register with me.
My mom actually calls him out regularly when he says something inappropriate, so it's not like my wife is the only person who notices.
Since having children, I've started recognizing these comments differently and have established clearer boundaries with him. But I admittedly still struggle with confronting him in the moment.
My wife feels like she's always the bad guy, that I roll over when my dad says something inappropriate, and that I don't stand up for her. She rarely confronts him herself, but she expects me to address these situations.
At the same time, I find myself getting frustrated because something I initially perceive as a relatively minor, stupid comment turns into a major argument between my wife and me. It's probably my least favorite recurring conflict in our marriage.
I've realized that I've spent years trying to avoid uncomfortable conversations with my dad, only to create much bigger conflicts with my wife. I also recognize that my wife isn't necessarily asking me to change my dad's entire personality. She wants to feel like I have her back without having to convince me every time.
But it's difficult. I love my dad, appreciate everything he's done for us, and genuinely don't believe he intends to hurt anyone. I also love my wife and don't want her to feel disrespected or unsupported.
There's always just this underlying tension whenever we're all together. I do feel that she can be a bit hard on him sometimes, like she's always just waiting for a reason to call him out on something. There was one time recently when he was describing where we lived to someone, and kept calling it a townhouse. She corrected him saying it's a duplex. He follows up with "Same thing", and she says "it's not though"...like come on, is that really needing to be corrected? I think she feels like he minimizes her sometimes.
Whenever they are interacting i get nervous. I don't want to constantly police everything my dad says, but I also don't want my wife to feel like she's alone in dealing with it.