I’ve tried supermarket together and the UI and organization drives me insane (re: needing to go back and forth for objects to organize the store) and doesn’t really have controller support. You can input controls for a gamepad but it’s really awkward.
for reference, I have a tremor and typically prefer using a xbox pro controller for my steam games and have some joint issues in my hands as well. I can do transactions in game with my mouse if needed, but for the main game I need controller support.
I tried the demo for better mart and liked it, don’t like that you can’t stack multiple things on the dolly (I’m a little meh that you have to take care of the crates yourself instead of them disappearing), but I DO like the ui and pretty much everything else and it was easy to use my controller until it came to using the register (which, eventually can have cashiers and I just switched to my mouse for the meantime which was fine, I just can’t do it for long). I also like that it has multiplayer but it’s not a deal breaker. I really liked that people asked for help (it was really funny when they would tell me they forgot what they needed or a dude asking me if I could see how big his arms are) and that they use carts and carrying baskets. I really like you can turn off cash transactions and turn them on for extra xp. the xp is a little addicting dopamine wise— definitely love the xp and unlocking things over time.
I noticed though that it doesn’t matter what I put out, everything is going to get sold anyway, and that’s a little frustrating since I have to replenish so much stock all the time.
I also have megastore simulator on my wishlist and it looks really good to me, but I don’t know how easy it is to use a controller (not steam deck) and there’s no demo. I like that you can stack crates and that there’s multiple departments and how the register is set up. Not crazy that you have to input the number for the credit card transactions, but that’s pretty typical in these. it wasn’t a thing in better mart and was really nice.
and of course there’s also supermarket simulator— no demo for that, either. I’ve seen the ui and it looks a little frustrating just because of how the grid works when setting things up and things not always lining up, and it’s really frustrating that there’s a lot of paid dlc, but I know it’s one of the top supermarket sim games. I do like that all tools are basically in your pockets instead of having to run back and forth with them like supermarket together. It also looks like it’s multiplayer? (can anyone confirm?)
I’m really not that interested in the card market game, just to note. I did also try leafy corner and it was super cute, in case there’s tiny ones like that one to try out.
I did look through the reddit btw and a lot of posts are pretty old and don’t go over the good and ugly of each game, just how they compare to each other. If anyone can provide quality of life features they’ve noticed in these i’d really appreciate it! hopefully this post will help other people w the same questions I have too :)
thanks!