(Before I start id like to say I loved all of season 4 and love mappa)

Imagine you just finished season 3 of breaking bad, and upon starting season 4 you realise; Everyone is played by a diffierent actor, the colour grading of the show is grey and washed out, the Camera used is clearly diffirent, and every building in ABQ looks different.

Surely the visual whiplash would be huge, Surely it would break your Immersion just a little, And that is exactly my problem with Mappas adaptation, it DOES NOT RESPECT WIT.

This might piss off the fans of the manga, but I have to say it; The consistancy of the Anime is A LOT more important than manga accurecy (visually)

My first and least excusable problem is the characters. The character designs (even if aged) should have stayed the same. We spent 59 episodes with these characters, seeing everyone look different AND aged was a heck of a visual whiplash. And the fact that aot changed studios does not excuse it. There are plenty of anime that changed studios that retained the character design consistancy some examples are KonoSuba, Vinland Saga Uma Usuma. Just retaining the orignal character designs

would make season 4 feel so much more cohesive.

Then theres Colour grading and composition, I liked season 4s overall style but it was nothing like the past seasons, everything was a lot more grounded and washed out, which while fitting for the tone was nothing like WIT.

There was a guy on youtube who used some software to simulate how season 4 would look with just WITS colour pallet, which perfectly shows what Im talking about:

https://youtu.be/sY0WnGZMREU?si=IbOako2qyQjXHcpA

Besides the big changes i wish mappa tried to stay more consistant with other smaller details, such as titan Transformation sounds, and visuals, Thunder spear flame colour (was very weird for season 4 to start with them have orange flames, then bluray randomly turning them Bright green for no apparent reason)

The titans I have the least issue with besides wishing for their designs to be closer to past seasons

But at the end of the day Im glad mappa finished aot🥹🙏

Hange was the worst commander of all time and I ain’t changing my mind. Erwin achieved a lot of things while being a commander than Hange or other commanders did.
- He managed to convince Levi (who wanted to kill Erwin) to join the survey corps and made Levi follow him as his leader.
- He also managed to pull off successfully overthrow the fake king and put a new queen without causing too much outrage.
- due to Hange mistake of losing to Reiner and Bertholdt in wall rose, Erwin had to fix the mistake and capture Eren by using horde of titans which no one would do.
- he knew that people were outside the walls before the basement but he just lacked the proof.
- Erwin also came up the plan to defeat beast titan in the battle where everyone thought that they would lose. The plan was successful and zeke had retreat with Reiner. Bertholdt died and paradis gained colossal titan.
-Gives the best speeches, he can turn a coward into a lion. He can convince people to die for him.

I also don’t remember anything that Hange achieved in all those years after Erwin died. I mean she couldn’t even convince Eren or handle the yeagerists.

Glazing Erwin is the reason, the heart still beats.

when I watching the biggining of breach I saw some different like the titan first casualties like it's actually being cut like it's likely an second not accurate an full minute and also some fight Scene to is missing

and you guy are wondering what I talking about

cause I actually still the DVD of aot live action when I rewatching it again it's actually so different

Anybody else feels this way? Since Eren's whole stick is an obsession with a free world (same way as satan wanted freedom from God's world order/authority). Plus eren literally becoming "The devil of all earth" towards the end of the series. I feel like if his ears are meant to represent "devil horns."

When Eren tells Reiner in the Liberio basement: 'I'm just like you,' it's about what they feel when doing things. After what he did, Reiner developed depression, suicidal guilt, and a general desire to die. If Eren had survived the Rumbling, he would have developed the same thing, but multiplied by 1000. So dying at Mikasa's hands was a kind of mercy.

As a lore watcher and someone who absolutely adores analyzing characters, I seem to be stuck. First of all, I absolutely love analyzing characters, my analysises aren't very long, usually around 400 - 800 words, so I seriously hit a gold mine when I started watching AOT the first time, I had a great time analyzing Mikasa, Ymir and Historia, Reiner, Bluetooth and a couple more.

But the problem is Eren, I understand him, but at the same time I don't? I even watched AOT again just to try to make a final analysis for him, and I did! But only a couple weeks later I found flaws and holes in my writing, so after a very, very long time ( a couple months) and after a lot of diving in Reddit and other sources for help, I decided to ask directly since I can't seem to get a good answer... What is your Eren Jaeger analysis?

Theres 2 more things I wanna add to this post, first of all I think it's best that I clarify what I'm having difficulty with IN VERY SHORT TERMS. Im hella confused about how Eren saw freedom, was the scenery in armins picture book like the embodiment of freedom? Also I researched about negative and positive freedom, and I understand that what Eren searched for was negative freedom and considered that to be freedom itself, while completely casting aside positive freedom. And since you aren't free without both of them, Eren wasn't free and it's what led to his downfall. Hmm but I also am not sure, maybe I'm overcomplicating this and Eren did search for both positive and negative freedom and it was his obsession that made him not free???? I don't know guys, I've been at this for weeks and I'm just really confused, and I can't seem to relax till I understand it.

The second thing is that, maybe the reason Eren is hard for me to analyze is that, me as a person have always had freedom as a goal aswell, I study hard so I can achieve the most freedom in my life. So maybe seeing him fail so badly is hard for me to get ( I Hope I don't sound cringe rn)

So, I would really appreciate any sort of analysis and explanations!

And I must say, what a journey! I was thinking about which language to rewatch the anime in for the third time, but decided to read the manga instead. And, in my opinion, it was 100% the right decision for me. It gave me an absolutely different experience.

First of all, I gained a better understanding of the world and the nature of relationships between certain characters. I noticed more details that helped me see some of the characters (Hange, Annie, Frieda, Zeke, Levi) in a new light. I discovered details/scenes that just weren't in the anime. There were also things I simply hadn’t noticed while watching the anime, but in the manga — thanks to the way the panels are laid out — they really caught my eye.

I have to admit that I don't like the ending and didn't like it before. But I found it easier to take in the events after the timeskip in the manga; for me personally, the plot progression felt smoother. I really liked the way Grisha’s memories of obtaining the Attack Titan were interspersed with the present-day events for Eren.

Character design, the depiction of emotional states/reactions, and shot composition (especially after the timeskip) are something! I much prefer how the characters look in the manga around the time of the fourth season compared to the anime (except Reiner, I guess).

And I finally picked up on Floch's character development.

I'm watching the netflix version of the anime and I've wondered why the cuts between scenes feel so jarring and I've realised its because I was used to seeing them inbetween scenes. Is it just like this for the anime on netflix? Why would they remove it?

IMO it’s hange. I feel like she was the most understanding and open minded of the team. She was also the most selfless.

In the early seasons her big nose had a distinct curve to it, it was so endearing to me. I knew something was different besides her hair being down, I just couldn’t put my finger on it. Now I’m rewatching and just realised; her nose isn’t hooked anymore.

Lets say Grisha was inside Shiganshina when the Colossal Titan breached the wall. What would've happened? Would he have fought Reiner and the titans off, or take Eren and the rest of the fam and dip?