r/ModernMagic • u/Organic-Conclusion-9 • 23h ago
If anything, Modern needs unbans, not bans.
Now that the new Rakdos aggro deck has overtaken Broodscale, which definitely had a target on its back, I've been thinking that this format needs unbans because of three reasons.
MH3 drastically increased the power level of the format, making bans from even the MH2 era unnecessary. You saw this most recently when Violent Outburst was unbanned and the most powerful deck of the end of the MH2 era, Rhinos, failed to make a dent in the format, and Living End barely budged.
Modern is a full turn faster than it used to be. Whereas older cards were banned for being too good for their mana value, many of them would help keep new strategies in check.
Some of the colors have gaping holes that banned cards fill, most notably green and black.
What I would like to see come off the ban list:
- Deathrite Shaman. We need main deck graveyard hate in the format given the power level of the delirium cards and how much easier it is to shove cards into the graveyard.
- Ponder. Control has been in the gutter ever since MH3 and Ponder would help control decks find their cards.
- Grief. Grief was not even powerful when it was banned and is great at disrupting combo decks. Vexing Bauble also exists which turns it into a liability past turn 1 or on the draw.
- Artifact lands. Affinity can already dump their hand early, and modern is fast enough to be able to handle artifact lands.
Those are the four things I would like to come off the ban list that would increase the diversity of the format and help with some of the swinginess we're seeing where new strategies come up that are hard to counter.