TLDR: Bought an "all solid mahogany guitar", broke it, repaired it in stages, over multiple years, finally found out it wasn't an "all solid mahogany guitar"
So..... I bought my first resonator guitar in 2012 right before I got married. It was a cheap SX model from Rondo Music, but somehow I managed to be so inspired by the instrument that I recorded a track with it that played at our wedding procession. Hey, I got hooked dobro! Obviously that was not a fine quality instrument, so after doing a bunch of research.... around 2014 I bought a Gold Tone "PBS-M: Paul Beard Squareneck Solid-Mahogany Resonator Guitar". It advertised all solid-wood contruction, and while it was made overseas, I trusted that the US-based setup would provide a great upgrade. I wasn't wrong! It was a great guitar. I played it on stage and in the studio like crazy!
And then.... tragedy....
Around 2016 I started playing with a funk/soul band (not much need for dobro), but I got a special request to play dobro on the first song for a show. I'd love to!
We were just the opening act, but first set, first song, first note....strap slips and the entire guitar violently plunges to the stage, creating a sound that was a car crash combined with a mic drop if the car was made of wood and the mic diaphragm was made of aluminum.. If you could make a room full of people sound like a sad trombone... well, that was the response from the crowd.
I recovered and quickly tuned, and got through the tune, embarrasingly. I was so devasted about what I'd find after the set.
Afterward.... I appraised the damage.... the shock was mostly to the lower back....The tail block had basically separated in mulitple areas.... The back had a huge crack along the binding, the top had started to split in the center. While I could still play the instrument, the gaps continued to grow. It needed professional help, but I was unable to find a luthier locally that wanted to deal with it, being unfamiliar with resonator guitars.
It sat on a shelf in my basement for years.
A few years ago, I got an urge to work on it, so I removed the neck, stripped and sanded that. I removed the back to be able to get to the tailstock. Worked on the back a bit... lots of sanding sealer...
Life got in the way, but last year I had more time to devote to the project. I picked up where I left off, and removed the finish off the top. The sanding sealer was a pain, but eventually got it prepped for finish.
Next came the sides..... no amount of chemical stripper, acetone, or anything else but some good old sanding had worked for the sealer on the top and back, so I decided to go straight to the sides with 120 grit on the random orbital sander. Soon I was through the finish, the sanding sealer, and starting to see the beautiful mahogany underneath all that finish.... and then..... a pale little circle forms.... and got bigger. I couldn't believe it! It was PLYWOOD!
I kinda froze.
I check the specs.... maybe it says solid-top and not solid body
Nope.... From Gold Tone's website:
Back & Sides Solid Mahogany
I gave them the benefit of the doubt. I went to the Wayback Machine on Archive.org as far back as 2012 and it has always been listed as having solid sides.
I'm a bit furious. I know it was my fault I broke the damn thing. I know they are not selling a guitar with expectations that someone wants to refinish it. But I wanted to fix it and make it look good again, and hey... I could just paint the sides and call it a day. But it just revealed something that might be pretty important to a company that's contracting with overseas builders. Was mine just a mistake? How many other so-called "all solid mahogany" guitars weren't made as such. It would be hard to tell unless you basically deconstructed/sanded it as I had, or maybe you can tell if you have drilled for pickup output jack and could determine if it solid?
I contacted Gold Tone and haven't received a response for a week. I posted my findings on one their Facebook posts and they reaplied assuring me I must have the plywood model... which doesn't make sense cause I have the snowflake inlays, maple binding, and solid wood top and back. I sent another followup with more evidence of my model's construction.
Anyways.... I'm leaving this here until Gold Tone responds. I'm not knocking plywood resonators. I've played quite a few that sound great, but don't upcharge me several hundred dollars for something I'm not getting. And hey, you could argue statute of limitations for how long ago I got it... but if this is a common occurence it could be class-action suit. Getting ahead of myself.... Just being mad. Be happy. Breathe.