r/whatcarshouldIbuy • u/jdanes52 • 2h ago
Can't decide on a car: Gone to VW, but want back to BMW
I currently own a 2020 Golf R Line (1.5tsi) and used to have a 2016 X3 20d m sport. I got rid of it as it was a heft diesel, I didn't do the miles and there were looming costs coming including brake pads, discs and I was worried about potential DPF issues. I also ended up servicing locally or Halfords which meant selling was difficult as didn't have full iDrive stamps.
A year on and I want to go back to BMW. Here are my shortlists all around £25k - £30k, and around 2020 year models or maybe a bit newer.
- BMW 330i
- BMW M340i
- BMW X3 20i
- Golf GTI
My initial feelings are the M340i is probably too quick and a bit unecessary. Concern is the X3 is just going to have the same future costs, tyres are pretty pricey for example. The golf is great, so cheap for insurnace, tax and amazing on fuel but I am missing that premium feeling and a bit of guts.
I work from home and don't need to commute anywhere, for now.
Any advice is much appreciated.