I have a 4-month-old Australian Labradoodle who's been home for almost a month. We started crate training right away, and he had already had some crate training with his breeder.
He's great in his crate at night! He sleeps from around 8 PM to 5 AM without any issues.
Daytime is a different story.
He sleeps peacefully in his crate if I'm nearby watching TV or reading, but as soon as I leave his sight, he often wakes up and starts whining or barking.
I've tried covering three sides of the crate and partially covering the front, along with white noise and calming music. He doesn't seem to dislike the crate itself. He just wants me nearby.
He's naturally very shy, cautious, and easily frightened, so I spent the first two weeks helping him settle in without pushing him too much.
For the past two weeks, I've been practicing short absences twice a day. We started with just stepping out of sight and coming right back, then gradually increased to 5 seconds, 10 seconds, and so on.
We're now entering our third week of training, and I can step outside through the front door for about a minute.
Luckily, I'm home most of the time, so there's no urgent need to leave him alone for long periods. But I'm starting to wonder if I'm taking things too slowly.
At this pace, getting to one or two hours feels so far away!
I've read that puppies need to learn to self-soothe and that some people simply leave them alone for 5–10 minutes, even if they whine or bark, and gradually increase the time. So I'm wondering if that approach might actually be better than what I'm doing now. I don't want to push him too hard, but I also don't want to be overly cautious and slow down his progress.
Other than this, he's a pretty easy puppy. He stayed with his breeder until 14 weeks old, around adult dogs and his littermates. He's never been mouthy with people, and surprisingly, he only plays with and chews his own toys. He's teething and chews his toys until they're practically falling apart, but he doesn't seem interested in chewing furniture, shoes, or other household items.
He's also very gentle with my children and our senior cat. I sometimes wonder if his cautious personality is why he seems so comfortable staying within familiar boundaries.
Am I doing the right thing by taking it this slowly? Does progress eventually speed up, or should I start encouraging him to self-soothe even if that means some whining? My goal is simply for him to feel comfortable being alone for an hour or two.
I'd really appreciate any advice or personal experiences. Thank you!