r/puppy101 • u/ElectricalWeek1866 • 18d ago
Update My Border Collie is 1.5 years old now. The biggest thing that changed wasn't him. It was me.
I remember being on this subreddit when my Border Collie was a puppy, desperately looking for reassurance that things would eventually get better.
Well, he's about 1.5 years old now, and I wanted to come back and share our story. Because if you're currently crying over your puppy, exhausted, overwhelmed, and wondering what you've gotten yourself into, I know that feeling very well.
When we first got him, he was covered in fleas and had intestinal parasites. We removed around 30 ticks from him. We were cleaning the entire house every single day, terrified that the bugs would spread. He pooped everywhere, had digestive issues, and those first weeks were a nightmare.
Then came this beautiful, peaceful phase where we thought we'd somehow ended up with the perfect dog. He learned a million tricks, was incredibly smart, and we were so proud of ourselves.
And then puberty hit.
Oh. My. God.
Suddenly he was pulling on the leash, ignoring us, and seemingly forgetting everything he'd ever learned. We tried so many things. Different training methods, different advice, different approaches.
And that was another huge part of the problem: everyone had an opinion.
You go online and one trainer tells you to do something. Another tells you that exact thing will ruin your dog. You go outside and suddenly every stranger is a dog trainer who knows exactly what you're doing wrong. Meanwhile, some people can't even manage their own dogs responsibly, and yours ends up paying the price despite being on a leash.
It was exhausting.
There were tears. Puppy blues. Sleepless nights. So much second-guessing. So many moments when I felt like I wasn't doing enough, or wasn't doing things correctly.
But today? Today, he's the best dog I could ever have hoped for.
He's incredibly affectionate with both me and my husband. He's obedient, funny, loving, and somehow makes even the worst days better just by being there.
I had surgery, and throughout my recovery he barely left my side. He just wanted to be close to me.
He's our little shadow, our adventure buddy, and such a huge part of our family. I genuinely cannot imagine our lives without him.
So what changed?
Of course, he grew up a bit. We kept working with him, and maturity helped a lot.
But I think the biggest change was that I finally relaxed.
I stopped treating every piece of advice from some random online trainer as a rule I absolutely had to follow. I stopped worrying so much about what my dog should be doing and started paying attention to the dog actually standing in front of me.
What does he enjoy? What does he need? What works for our family?
For example:
Dog parks? I know they're controversial, but yes, we go. He loves chasing his frisbee and hanging out with the few dog friends he's made there. He couldn't care less about most other dogs. He's happy sharing toys, water, and even food without drama. We pay attention to the dogs and the environment, and we leave if things don't feel right.
Crate training? Nope. We tried, but it just wasn't working for us, and eventually I didn't see a reason to force it. We gradually taught him to stay home alone, got a camera to check on him, and he's completely fine. He doesn't destroy anything.
Sleeping in our bedroom or even in our bed? Absolutely. If he's cold or wants cuddles, he climbs into bed. If he's too warm, he moves to the floor or his own little bed. If the house is too noisy during the day, he takes himself to the bedroom for a nap.
Constant exercise because he's a Border Collie? Nope.
Some days we have big adventures, play frisbee, explore, and do lots of activities. Other days we just take short walks around the neighborhood for bathroom breaks and spend the rest of the day relaxing.
And you know what? He's fine.
Border Collies need rest too. Not every day needs to be an exhausting marathon of physical and mental stimulation.
I'm not saying our choices are right for every dog. They're probably not. And that's exactly my point.
Dogs are individuals.
What works beautifully for one dog might be completely wrong for another. And I wish I'd understood that sooner instead of spending so much time worrying about whether I was following all the rules.
I'm also not saying you should ignore genuine behavioral problems or stop training your puppy. We still put in the work. But training became so much easier when I stopped obsessing over doing everything perfectly and started enjoying my dog.
We learned to understand each other.
Now we're our own little family. We go everywhere together when we can, and I wouldn't trade him for anything in the world.
Getting through those early puppy blues was one of the best decisions I've ever made.
So if you're struggling right now, here's what I wish someone had told me:
Your puppy doesn't need you to follow every piece of advice on the internet. They need you to get to know them.
Give them time to grow. Give yourself permission to make mistakes. Pay attention to what makes your dog happy, what overwhelms them, when they need activity, and when they just need to sleep.
And please, don't forget to actually enjoy the little creature you're working so hard to raise.
One day you just might look at that same puppy who made you cry from exhaustion and realize they're your favorite part of coming home.
That's what happened to us. ❤️