r/phillies • u/TheAthletic • 25d ago
Article [Ken Rosenthal] These Phillies can’t get it done. It’s time for dramatic action.
Click the link above and debate in comments for free [no paywall:
OK, that’s enough. Time for Philadelphia Phillies president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski to concede his collection of well-paid stars isn’t getting it done. Time for him to take dramatic steps to overhaul his roster.
How, you ask?
Not sure. But Dombrowski, too, is well-paid. And it’s his job to figure it out.
Moving Trea Turner from shortstop to center field? That should be automatic, assuming the Phillies can’t trade him. Trading Bryce Harper or Kyle Schwarber? Don’t love the idea, but everything needs to be under consideration. Everything.
The Phillies are not going to rebuild, not when they’re still drawing 3 million fans to Citizens Bank Park, not when their three best starting pitchers — Zack Wheeler, Jesús Luzardo and Cristopher Sánchez — are under contract through 2027, 2031 and 2032, respectively.
Dombrowski, though, cannot bring back the same club. And if owner John Middleton is wedded to the team’s stars — he gives no indication to the contrary — then Dombrowski will need to build a much stronger supporting cast.
The Phillies’ 6-2 loss to the Atlanta Braves in the wild-card clincher Thursday night marked their fourth straight year of regression in the postseason since appearing in the 2022 World Series.In 2023, they lost the NLCS to the Arizona Diamondbacks after returning home with a three-games-to-two lead. In ’24 and ’25, they lost in the Division Series to the New York Mets and the Los Angeles Dodgers, respectively. And this season, they nearly blew a five-game lead for a playoff berth with eight to play, then got knocked out in the wild-card round.
Hiring Alex Cora to replace interim manager Don Mattingly might be Dombrowski’s first move, but to what end? Cora, Dombrowski’s manager with the 2018 World Series champion Boston Red Sox, isn’t going to walk into the Phillies’ clubhouse and sprinkle magic pixie dust on a club that clearly is trending in the wrong direction.
A number of the Phillies’ most prominent players — from Harper to Schwarber to Turner; Wheeler to Aaron Nola to J.T. Realmuto — are 33 or older. The team is inconsistent offensively, shoddy defensively and haunted by Dombrowski’s historic inability to build a quality bullpen.
Other than that, all is well.
Some of the Phillies’ turnover will occur naturally, with first baseman Alec Bohm, second baseman Luis Arraez and left-handed reliever José Alvarado likely to depart as free agents. Dombrowski can also maneuver around the edges, perhaps by trading left fielder Brandon Marsh, whose stock plummeted with a horrid second half. But the Phillies aren’t likely to get much help from their farm system.