r/nonmonogamy • u/Necessary-South-5764 • 19m left
Relationship Dynamics Poly wife, compersive husband: her lover is back and a date is coming. Tips for the day itself and beyond?
M51, together ~20 years, married 11. My wife F43 is polyamorous, I’m monogamous but compersive (closest label: stag, though I’m not present). What I love is her being desired and flirty, and that energy coming back to me. She shares stories and photos with me, which is what makes it work.
In 2024 she fell in love with a married man (“Paul”, M47). It’s a real emotional connection for her, not just sex. They met 3 times, the last in September 2024. Then he pulled back: very little contact, she’d write, he’d answer briefly, plus a few brief encounters at events (he’s a musician). He told her he wanted them both to forget each other.
A couple of weeks ago he told her he couldn’t forget her and wanted to see her again, and he keeps saying so since. A date was set, he postponed it to “early November” with no exact date. His messages are sparse: she replies right away, he can take several days. He uses a separate number his wife doesn’t know about, maybe he keeps it switched off, we don’t really know. It’s frustrating for her.
The first night they spent together was really hard for me, the other two went well. I want to do better this time:
- How do you handle the evening itself, waiting at home?
- How do you deal with overthinking? I’m sleeping badly and replaying everything.
- How do you support your partner when the lover is distant or pulls back, without saying “I told you so”?
- Did you use any guides, books or resources that really helped?
- Did you write down your own rules as a couple? A kind of “ten commandments”, except “thou shalt not covet thy neighbor’s wife” becomes “thou shalt let the neighbors covet thy wife” 😄 What’s on your list?