r/netflix • u/FakeTalesOfGiorgio • 17h ago
Discussion Better Call Saul might be better than Breaking Bad. So why didn’t it win a SINGLE Emmy?
Breaking Bad won 16 Emmy Awards out of 58 nominations.
Better Call Saul? 53 nominations. Zero wins.
Let that sink in for a moment.
Both shows were created by Vince Gilligan and feature incredible writing, complex characters, and some of the best performances in television.
Yet, despite six seasons of critical acclaim, Better Call Saul never won a single Primetime Emmy. Not even Bob Odenkirk or Rhea Seehorn managed to take home an award for their performances.
Personally, I think Better Call Saul deserves to be considered on the same level as Breaking Bad. In some ways, its character development, subtle storytelling, and psychological depth are arguably even better. Jimmy McGill’s transformation is just as fascinating as Walter White’s, if not more so.
Of course, Breaking Bad is more intense, accessible, and gripping. But does that automatically make it the better show?
Was Better Call Saul simply unlucky to compete against shows like Game of Thrones, Succession, and The Handmaid’s Tale? Did being a prequel prevent it from receiving the recognition it deserved? Or is Breaking Bad genuinely the superior series?
Here’s the real question: if Better Call Saul had aired first, without Breaking Bad casting such a long shadow over it, would we consider it the better show today?
I’m curious to hear what everyone thinks. Which series do you prefer? And does the fact that Better Call Saul never won a single Emmy change your perception of the show in any way?
