r/matheducation • u/justwannaedit • 1h ago
How to teach with fidelity when students have seemingly insurmountable learning gaps
We are instructed to teach our curriculum with fidelity. I am all for this, but today I had a really hard time with it.
I am teaching Algebra 1 to eighth graders. Because it's an algebra 1 curriculm, the curriculm assumes they mastered numerous things from 8th grade math.
So for instance today, they were supposed to create equations to represent the graphs of numerous lines. Much of the lesson focused on when to use point slope form as opposed to standard form or slope intercept form.
I realized immediately in the lesson though that students had never seen point slope form. They only just learned standard form yesterday. So, I felt like it made sense to slow down the lesson and try to actually explain point slope form.
I was being informally observed, and I was told I spent too long on the beginning of the lesson, which the curriculm dictates should be something like 5 minutes.
But if students could not do the first few problems at all, I didn't realize what sense it would make for them to attempt way harder problems.
The admin also wants to see students engaging in rich mathematical discussion, using specific sentence starters, to discuss the content. But again, I dont see how they are supposed to have a discussion about something that to them amounts to nothing but a soup of random math symbols.
I really want to please my admin but it's feeling more and more like an impossible gap between expectation and reality.
My students tell me I am a great teacher, and I know part of that is because I am a patient and understanding teacher (I always got that feedback when I tutored, too.) But whenever I get observed it makes me feel like I'm terrible.
And admin seems to expects much better behavior from the kids too. Sometimes they will have quiet little conversations about the math while I am demonstrating something, but I'm fine with a little noise as long as things stay in control and on task. But I got feedback today too that the students weren't well behaved enough, and that terrifies me because that class is by far my best behaved class so like if they aren't good enough for admin, I worry that I am completely doomed.
Any help highly appreciated!!