On tape, school board member Carlos Leyva says Mayor Muellerwanted the SBCSC investigation stopped. Leyva refused.
In January 2025, the South Bend school board hired two outside investigators to look into five years of conduct by district administrators and board members. Board member Carlos Leyva said the board needed protection. Then-Superintendent Todd Cummings had been threatening the board, Leyva said.
South Bend Mayor James Mueller wanted to know why. Leyva said Mueller pointed at him and said, “You’re creating chaos.”
In August 2025, Leyva told the investigators that Mueller wanted the investigation stopped.
“Mueller said he wants to put a stop to the investigation,” Leyva told investigator Tim Corbett, a former Metro Homicide Commander, in a recorded call.
Leyva said Mueller came to him twice, in March and June 2025, and called him a swing vote. “You can stop it,” Leyva quoted Mueller.
Leyva said he told Mueller he would see the investigation through to the end, then asked Mueller what he wanted.
“I want to get all this investigation stuff over,” Leyva quoted Mueller.
On the recorded call, Corbett asked Leyva why the mayor wanted the investigation stopped.
“Because his friends are involved,” Leyva said.
“McBride and Kareemah”
Leyva quoted Mueller naming “McBride and Kareemah.”
Kareemah Fowler, a Democrat, was elected city clerk with Pete Buttigieg’s endorsement. Cummings hired her in 2019 to run the district’s finances. State auditors later found $767,585 in questioned costs in the district’s 2022-2023 spending and referred their findings to the Indiana Attorney General and the St. Joseph County Prosecutor, Redress South Bend reported in May. Fowler signed the agreements behind two $25,000 checks the district paid Democratic council member Karen White personally, Redress reported in January.
Sharon McBride is a Democratic member of the South Bend Common Council. In a text to Corbett, Leyva wrote, “Mueller was pissed that you \[Corbett\] were investigating McBride.”
Leyva also named “Shiela \[Niezgodski\]” among friends Leyva said Mueller sent to press him to end the investigation.
In 2020, Mueller, Cummings, Fowler, White, McBride, and Niezgodski appeared in videos asking voters to approve the district’s $166.4 million referendum.
Leyva also told Joe Speybroeck, the board’s second investigator and a former St. Joseph County sheriff, about Mueller’s pressure. According to Speybroeck’s written statement, Leyva said Mueller wanted the investigators to “lay off on Kareemah a little bit…back off a little.”
Leyva texted Corbett that Mueller “wanted to know what was in your binder,” meaning Corbett’s, and that Leyva texted Mueller back that it was “not his business.” When Redress read those messages back to Leyva on Oct. 19, 2026, Leyva said, “I remember that.”
**“I haven’t succumbed”**
Leyva did not end the investigation. Leyva said refusing cost him a place on the city’s Redevelopment Commission.
“I felt like I was retaliated against by the highest-ranking official,” Leyva said. “It was hurtful, and I felt like it was personal.”
Corbett confirmed he possesses an audio recording of the call. Corbett provided Redress a transcript of that call, text messages between Leyva and Corbett, and Speybroeck’s written statement.
Redress called Mueller’s office and cell phone on Oct. 13, 2026, and sent him text messages on Oct. 13 and Oct. 19. Mueller read the messages and did not respond.
“I was getting attacked on both sides by Cummings, and now I was getting attacked by Mueller,” Leyva said. **“I haven’t succumbed to any pressure since I’ve been on the board.”**
“It was a tough decision with the investigation,” Leyva said, “but I felt like it was the right thing to do to fix the problems the schools had.”