329
u/polacs 1d ago
The worst part about AI is that a lot of people in this subreddit now has 0 clue about programming
→ More replies (13)
1.5k
u/shred-i-knight 1d ago
everyone here is simply larping as a dev if they think this is true. Debugging with AI is nearly painless compared to how it was before, and that is for significantly more code/product to debug at once as well.
→ More replies (446)
1.1k
u/SaltMaker23 1d ago
Nah it isn't. I'm all in for AI and vibe bashing but this is simply false.
What AI builds in couple of minutes (although not 2) would have taken weeks if not months to build.
It's harder to debug a significantly bigger product than it is to debug 2 hours of manual work that barely addressed a feature.
The last 10% of the work represent 90% of the time, obviously AI gets everyone a lot closer to being production ready, where the actual challenges become quite clear and it becomes increasingly harder to prompt away the problems and inconsistencies.
→ More replies (140)
55
u/Retsyn 1d ago
I think it handles the debugging vastly better than the writing. It's the writing I have huge reservations about.
→ More replies (14)
28
50
u/Vyrnin 1d ago
I find that AI is good at purely technical things, and bugs are a good example of that. They are usually simple mistakes in syntax, errors in logic, etc. Finding a bug is like editing a paper, you're just looking for the mistake.
When it comes to creative design, game feel, system architecture and art direction, that's where the human element is indispensable. These things are the real heart of the experience you're giving to the player. It takes emotion, intention, artistry and humanity to bring a really excellent story or experience to life, and to affect other humans in a meaningful way.
→ More replies (25)
108
u/Beldarak 1d ago
This sub really lives in another reality than mine or your code is really unique and weird.
"Claude, do this"
Claude did it. Oh, there's a bug.
"Claude, there is an issue, when I do X and expect Y, Z happens instead. And I get this in console [pasted stuff]"
Repeat a few times if necessary.
Done. As usual, I get why people may be against AI, I don't like it either for all the ethical reasons. Claming it doesn't work though is lunacy. You're all programers but can't prompt an LLM correctly?
→ More replies (44)
150
u/ccmaru1 1d ago
Are everyone here larping being a developer? ðŸ˜
AI literally sucked the soul and fun of something I value deeply but it’s better than almost every dev out there. A task list that would take me 1-2 days normally was done in 20 minutes while in a meeting with a project manager. I hate it but it’s sadly very… very good. At least Opus is.
→ More replies (104)
64
u/maladaptiveman 1d ago edited 1d ago
I think the reason you can't debug it in 24 hours with AI is you don't understand what you’re doing at all
→ More replies (2)
23
67
u/Senor-Delicious 1d ago
At this point I am convinced that people in this sub making these posts have zero experience with AI assisted development.
I've never debugged and analyzed anything as fast as with AI. Like not even close. Takes me minutes where I potentially required days before.
→ More replies (10)
134
u/PashaPostaaja 1d ago edited 1d ago
AI has made also debugging lot easier.
Are you actually using the AI or just pulling this from ares?
→ More replies (20)
18
u/Bannon9k 1d ago
This comic was made by a shitty developer. 6 hours debugging code you spent 2 hours writing?
→ More replies (1)
91
u/eW4GJMqscYtbBkw9 1d ago
2 hours coding (before AI)??? I've spent 2 days on one small bug that AI could have fixed in 90 seconds.
This meme is so stupid, I'm not convinced that the creator has actually ever coded before.
→ More replies (48)
68
u/eoThica 1d ago
Before cars:
Walking: 6 hours
Car repairs: 0
After cars
Driving: 2 hours
Walking: 6 hours
Car repairs: 29
→ More replies (1)
13
66
u/IllustriousGerbil 1d ago
This was true around the middle of last year.
Its absolutely not true now, AI written code is generally less buggy when you first run it than human written code.
→ More replies (8)
41
12
u/MilleryCosima 1d ago
The "24 hours debugging" thing has only been true for projects where I am completely out of my depth and should have done it by hand to learn the ropes anyway, like when I casually tried a data science project without know how to do data science.
6
24
u/AbilityCharacter7634 1d ago
I’m just an amateur coder, but even me can say reality is very different than this meme depicts.
Oh sure someone who never coded anything by themselves will have an absolute hell of a time debugging any somewhat complex project done by AI.
But if you know enough about coding, then you have enough intuition to know where something went wrong if you did enough effort to manage how the ai structured your code.
Plus just by the explosion in quantity of new mods and games that are halfway decent, AI does seem to increase productivity in some ways at least.
→ More replies (1)
11
4.2k
u/WisePotato42 1d ago
This meme seems a bit outdated. All the debugging has been outsourced to AI.