r/PolyFidelity • u/Skarlett_Ravynn • 1d ago
seeking advice New to closed triad - seeking advise
Hey yall! I'm somewhat new to this and just seeking general advise as well as some specific advise. I have some trauma from past relationships when I was much younger and just want to make sure I'm doing this right and not letting my past influence this relationship.
The situation:
I (26F) and my husband (28M, we'll call him Enzo) were out with a friend (23F, we'll call her Violet). Enzo and Violet have known each other for a few years but weren't super close. I met Violet within the past year. I have hung out with Violet more than Enzo has in the few years they've known each other.
Anyway, we were all hanging out at a festival, drinking and such, and I kissed her. That lead to us making out on the car ride home and then the 3 of us had a threesome. Totally unplanned, wasn't seeking it out, just hanging with a friend and it happened.
A few days later, we all sat down and talked about it and we're all open to exploring where this could go as a closed triad. We have at this point had 3 threesomes and each was better than the last.
This last time before we all had sex, we had another talk. Enzo and I talked to Violet seperately and then all 3 of us together. She expressed concerns to Enzo about being a disposable 3rd and wanting to be our girlfriend and he reassured her that's not what we want, we want her to be our girlfriend. To me (our conversation was after theirs) she said about being monogomous fwb. I expressed my concerns to her about wanting a romantic relationship with her and not just being 'tolerated' so her and Enzo can be together. She keeps saying I'm very attractive but kinda avoiding the emotional aspect. She did say she wouldnt have picked a female to be in a relationship next but she was open to trying it and she's a bit rusty in that aspect (she recently got out of a 3 year relationship with a man but has dated women in the past). My conversation with Violet was interrupted by our doordash order arriving. We then went into the conversation between the 3 of us and I again brought up about wanting her and I to have an emotional/ romantic relationship and she agreed (but it was like "yeah" while laying on his chest not looking at me). She is amazing towards me in bed tho, best I've had with a woman she honestly surprised me (she licked her way to my heart lmao, but I was into her before that too). Not trying to cast him in a bad light, its just how he is, he's not very big on the emotional/ romantic aspect of relationships so the romantic connection she wants will be more with me than him and I tried explaining that. (I'm not saying he won't care for her, I'm more saying the "treasuring" high emotion/ romance she seeks will come more from me bc that's how I am).
The trauma:
I was in a relationship with a man when I was in my late teens-early 20s. We had threesomes and some triad situations but the way it happened wasn't okay with me nor was my opinion taken into account ever if it was even asked for (usually wasnt). Basically, unbeknownst to me, he was out dating around and would bring them home to me. Like literally one of our girlfriends was introduced to me as my girlfriend. "Hey meet X, she's our girlfriend now" uhhh nice to meet you for the first time ever.. new girlfriend? Anyway, all of these people aside from 1 literally just tolerated my existence in order to be with my man. I am bisexual and have dated women and I want to date women but I am EXTREMELY scared of just being tolerated so they can be with my now husband (different man). I want a girlfriend that wants me.
My concerns:
Violet has assured me she is attracted to me (physically) but hasn't been very reassuring that she's interested in me as a person. I have multiple times expressed my past trauma and concerns about being tolerated to be with my man and how I actually want her and I to have a relationship (I'm actually into her, I caught feelings). It is still very new, we dont know each other very well so I'm not sure if I'm overthinking it (I'm a chronic overthinker) or if that is what she's doing and is just telling me it isn't.
She does seem to favor Enzo right now, which I chalk up to them just knowing each other longer and I understand our relationships are likely to develop at differing rates. Im just worried I'm setting myself up for heartbreak. I actually really like this girl and I'm scared its going to be a repeat of past relations I've had.
Pregnancy - this honestly wasn't something I had concerns about previously becuase Enzo has a tendency to not cum during threesomes. It was a rule we set just in case that he cant cum in anyone aside from me until we make the decision altogether otherwise. We've had a few one-off threesomes in the past (also not planned, nor "hunted" for) and he didnt cum and in past threesomes before I came into the picture he also hadn't cum. He said its been over a decade since he's cum during a threesome. So it really wasn't something I was too concerned about. Welp, he did cum during this last threesome while he was fucking Violet. He pulled out but it was VERY close (im not convinced he got out in time, like he said he was gonna cum, I told him to get out, he quickly thrusted a few more times then pulled out & the moment he was out he was cuming I'm really not convinced he got out fully in time). His pull-out game isn't as strong as it once was, he's finished inside me for the past 2 years. Now I'm very nervous about her being pregnant. Don't get me wrong, if this relationship works out and we are together for years, that's something I'd be open to in the future but RIGHT NOW its so new that I am not okay with it. Enzo and I have a young toddler and its just a complication we dont need right now. Its not something the 3 of us have talked about yet. I know in the relationship she recently left, they were trying and had miscarried multiple times and she's had very strong baby fever so I'm also concerned if she IS pregnant she will want to keep it. We're still in the window for Plan B and I want her to take it but I dont want to insult her by trying to have her take it. Idk what to do about that. This is all too new for that kinda complication, I dont want to scare her off by asking her to take a Plan B, I dont know what I'd do if she does end up pregnant and wants to keep it and is successful. Like I want her to have her own child, I'm not trying to gatekeep her uterus its just too new between the 3 of us. I really hate this complication popped up so early, I really like her.
Favortism? Some added context, I'm terrible at texting. I text like I'm talking in person so I write paragraphs which takes time that I dont always have bc I have a young toddler I'm chasing around. However, when someone grabs my attention I'm very talkative and make the extra effort to text them to show my interest. Violet and Enzo text much more often and I've had a bit of a feeling towards her not initiating conversations with me. I've asked Enzo about it and he is the one that typically initiates conversation with Violet but even so she is much more responsive to him (even when I initiate conversation). Maybe I'm just not as good at shooting the breeze in texts as he is. But there was a situation the last time we hang out. She texted him "lmk when yall are on ur way to get me". I texted her "omw" about 5 mins later. I got there and waited for her for an hour, calling texting having him call and text and I was very worried for her safety. When she finally responds, she responded to him that she was pulled into an unexpected work meeting. Its not until a good 30-45 mins later that she responds to me, the one freaking out about her safety (irrelevant other situation not related to this situation but I was getting ready to call the cops concerned). That really heightened the feeling of favoritism imo.
My questions:
Am I overthinking and letting my past trauma project onto Violet?
Is the wording differences between their conversation and our conversation something to be concerned about? Like does she want to be his girlfriend but just fwb with me? She's been unclear with her intentions despite Enzo and I trying to clarify individually and as a group.
Is that really just the case is that her history with Enzo is why she seems to favor him more right now? (Which is okay, I'm okay with our relationships developing at different rates I just dont want to end up being 'tolerated') she once said she is interested in me as a girlfriend and views him more as a best friend. I'm kinda falling for this girl but being hesitant letting myself fall completely becuase of this (my past + the seeming favoritism).
How should I approach the Plan B? Should I be worried about offending her? Should I present it with a more in-depth conversation about how it would be something we can do in the future if we work out but right now she needs to take the Plan B? I know she's sensitive about pregnancy and dont want to hurt her feelings but I need that reassurance she won't get pregnant right now. (We only went unprotected bc we all know we're clean right now & Enzo doesnt (or rather didnt) cum during threesomes but I dont think she's on birth control bc she was trying for pregnancy somewhat recently - ik ik it was stupid of us to go unprotected in the first place but my mind was more on STD concerns than pregnancy bc of Enzo's tendancy and we knew she was clean).
I just want to make sure I'm doing this properly. I care about her and her feelings. We've talked about what she wants in this relationship and her boundaries as well as ours. I dont want her to feel "unicorn hunted" or as a "disposable 3rd". I genuinely like her and hope to have a long triad relationship with her. But I have trauma and concerns.
I am open to criticism. If I'm overthinking or doing something wrong, please tell me but be kind about it. I want the best for her and our relationship and that's why I'm here making this post. I dont need hatred spewed at me I'm a sensitive soul.
TLDR:
Situation - out with a mutal friend (more history between him & her than her & I), had an unplanned threesome, now are easing into a triad relationship.
Trauma - I tried triad in the past with a different man and it didnt go well at all. Without conversation & permission he was out dating around and would bring women home to be in a relationship with us without my opinion and I was often unwillingly cucked both in bed and the relationship, I was 'tolerated' so they could sleep with my man.
Concerns - I'm worried about projecting my past onto Violet. I'm concerned with her being unclear on her intentions. She's said conflicting things like her and I being platonic and fwb but then also saying things like she's more interested in me and views him as a best friend. Concerned about a current pregnancy scare very early on in our new relationship. Favoritism concerns, not sure if our relationships are developing at differing rates or if I'm setting myself up for heartbreak.
Questions - am I projecting? Am I overthinking? How to handle this pregnancy scare? (I seem to be the only one concerned). Developing at different rates or actual favoritism?
Wrap up thoughts - I'm really into her and want to make sure I'm handling this properly and not letting my past & anxieties ruin a good thing. (Sorry for the book of a read)