Okay, story time because I'm awestruck by how well today's lesson went (despite almost falling off once).
There's this lesson horse I haven't ridden in about a year, he's the definition of dead to the leg, so unmotivated that he trips over his own feet sometimes, but you can't ride him with a crop because he's scared of crops. So a shitty combo.
So far, whenever I rode him, it was frustrating. He was lazy, I could barely make him trot sometimes, and he would slow down the second I stopped using my legs. Cantering? No chance. Some other students ride him with spurs because he won't move forward (I know, that's not what spurs are for).
So today, there was a bit of a holdup and I had to wait about 15 minutes on top of the 15 minutes of leading before the lesson started. I figured I'd use this time to just play around a bit. I did hindquarter yields, stopping, backing up, doing various patterns around some cones on the ground, and leg yielding.
I used the loop of the reins and wiggled it to create some energy or gave him a little tap whenever he fell behind or wouldn't back up. It caused him to go "oh shit" for a moment, but nothing drastic, so I eventually had a good grasp of how much energy he needed and how much would be too much.
Once I was in the saddle, he marched. The trot was motivated, he blew out quite a few times right off the bat. Once he got a little too slow and wouldn't react to my leg, I took the reins in one hand and tapped his shoulder with the loop again. He went "oh, sorry" and picked up the pace again. We cantered, and he was overall a good boy. I kept him busy with lots of transitions and circles and direction changes so he wouldn't go on autopilot, and he seemed very content.
What's funny is that in the past, I tried that "slap them on the neck with the loop of the reins" trick but it never worked, or maybe it worked for a step or two and then he was lazy again. And I think it was because I was always scared of him exploding or taking off with me (he does that sometimes when he gets startled). But today I had this mentality "we're going forward, and I'm not scared of you getting scared". And it worked??
He did take off one time together with another horse because someone's stirrup bumped against the wall of the arena and it was pretty loud. I almost fell off but managed to stay on after my instructor yelled "SIT BACK, STAY ON" about 10 times in a row, and once I regained my balance I kept on cantering on a circle and just acted like cantering was my idea anyway. He calmed down pretty fast after that.
I think this is what they mean when they say "ride proactively, not reactively". I did not expect those 15 minutes prior to riding to make such a difference, but it seems this is exactly what this horse needed. I've ridden him so many times before, and never did I feel like he was paying ANY attention to me. Today changed everything and it was amazing.