It didn't happen on purpose. I watched Spirited Away as an adult years ago and disliked it; I remember liking the visuals and music but feeling like the story was just "arbitrary things happen". But My Neighbor Totoro (1988) came up in a list of good movies for younger kids, so we tried it. And holy shit, nothing happens in it.
Nothing happens, yet I and my children (5 y/o and 3 y/o) were enraptured by it.
Since then we've also watched Kiki's Delivery Service (1989) and The Secret World of Arrietty (2010), and to a lesser extent it's the same thing: the pace is so slow, and the stakes are so low, yet the whole family loved them.
To explain, let me summarize the plot of these movies as briefly as I can:
- My Neighbor Totoro: Two girls and their dad move to a house in the country to be closer to their mom in hospital. The girls encounter magical creatures.
- Climax: The younger sister gets lost. The two deal with their feelings over their mom's illness.
- Kiki's Delivery Service: A young witch sets off to a new city to live on her own for a year. Has challenges integrating and finding work.
- Climax: An airship crashes due to high winds. She doesn't save it, she just saves (with difficulty) one friend who was in danger.
- The Secret World of Arrietty: A family of doll-sized people live in secret under a house. A boy discovers them and tries to befriend them.
- Climax: A mean adult captures the tiny mom. The tiny girl and the human boy work together to save her, and help the tiny family escape to find somewhere new to live.
And for comparison, here's my attempt at summarizing Frozen (2013) in the same way:
- Frozen: Two sisters are royalty. One has ice powers and is told to hide them. She can't hide them, and runs away, which makes things worse. Her sister goes to find her and help her.
- Climax: People are trying to kill the girl with powers and take control of her kingdom. The sister's love saves them and makes things better again.
As you can see, the Ghibli movies sound pretty analogous to regular kid problems, whereas I can't explain Frozen without referencing things kids can't relate to at all (royalty, politics, supernatural powers). Yet you don't care that nothing happens in the Ghibli movie. Why? Well, I've been trying to put my finger on the reasons why. Here's what I've got:
- They're stories kids can relate to. Totoro is about kids dealing with a difficult family situation. Kiki is about a kid grappling with independence and an emotional slump. Arrietty is about finding courage, understanding people different than you, and saying goodbye to friends when moving house. There's no romance, no evil plots, no adult protagonists, no princesses, no Chosen One, just challenges and struggles much like kids would encounter in their own lives.
- The fantasy elements add to the story, but they don't define it. You could strip out the magic/fantasy elements and still basically tell the same story. I think this further helps kids relate to the story.
- Kids can follow the dialogue. It's spoken conspicuously slowly and clearly in simple language, so kids can understand it and follow the plot.
- The slow pace gives kids time to process. In one scene of My Neighbour Totoro, we spend like 30 seconds just on the mom telling the girl her hair is done up nicely and makes her look like mom. And then the scene ends. But it's not boring, because while it's happening, you're reflecting on what it says about their relationship; how highly the girl thinks of her mom, and how loving the mom is. Young kids in particular benefit from this time IMO, because they don't intuit these things like adults do; the slow pace gives them time to think about what just happened and what it means. It also gives adults time to reflect on the underlying themes that kids might not notice.
- Not having much action means that when there is action, it's very tense. When a Disney movie shows the characters nearly dying a dozen times in a row in a wacky action scene, you lose all tension and then things need to be dialed up to gigantic stakes just to find some tension again. But in Kiki's Delivery Service, the climax is literally just Kiki flopping around trying to get control of an unfamiliar broom to try to grab her friend's hand so he doesn't fall to his death. 30 seconds of just that. And yet my 5 y/o had my arm in a vice and was shaking with fear, more scared than she's ever been watching a movie.
It's jarring now going back to a Disney kids movie that's full of wacky characters, fast witty dialogue, intense action scenes, a plot that young kids can't follow, and that's constantly flashing something new on the screen as if it's afraid it's about to lose the child's attention. And all my girls ask for now is to re-watch these Ghibli movies, so they seem to be feeling the same, at least for the time being.
I'm not saying Disney movies are bad by any means, but this made me realize that we'd been showing the kids a pretty narrow range of movie styles, and it's been a breath of fresh air to branch out to something different. I'd recommend My Neighbor Totoro for preschool / early school-aged kids since it's definitely the slowest and simplest, Kiki's Delivery Service and Arrietty worked well for us too, and we have Ponyo (2008) and The Cat Returns (2002) also on our list too. There are several other Studio Ghibli movies I haven't looked into, since the consensus on them seemed to be that they're best for older kids than mine.
I will also admit that, as a father of two girls, all three movies I mentioned above are ones with a teen/pre-teen girl protagonist who is coming of age and is courageous, kind, helpful, persistent, and overall just an admirable (yet realistically flawed) character, so it hits me right in the feels.
I would be happy to hear any other suggestions of kids movies that are similar in being slower and simpler yet no less entertaining!