r/AskAnAfrican • u/bisousbisous2 • Nov 27 '25
Diaspora What do you think of Black Americans who build their identity and style around Africa?
Scrolling and came across a picture of a Black woman in America with a big Africa necklace, an Africa tattoo, and a kanga. Now I have no idea what this specific woman's background is, but I know there are plenty Black Americans who are very far removed from their roots and heavily incorporate at least the concept of Africa into their personal style and identity. It got me thinking about Americans of Italian descent who's entire identity revolves around the notion of being Italian, despite never having been to Italy, family not having spoken Italian for generations, etc. These people are, in my experience, quite disliked in Italy. Obviously Italian-Americans and African-Americans had extraordinarily different stories in America, and to me the Black Americans who strongly build their identity around Africa despite being very far removed from any specific African culture, language, etc. are understandably trying to reclaim an aspect of their personal identity and history that was so forcibly removed. But it got me wondering if, outside of America, this sort of behavior is seen the same across groups (regardless of African-Americans having a very different history than any other demographic who may do this) and if people in Africa often have the same sort of reaction as how Italians react to this specific subset of Italian-Americans?
ETA: Thank you all so far for the interesting discussion. It sounds like for the most part, people are quite supportive as long as the american in question is being respectful and genuine. It's particularly interesting to see how many responses affirm that it's their culture so it's no problem/welcomed. The only dynamic I'm familiar enough with to draw comparisons is the aforementioned subset of Italian-Americans, and in my experience the most common sentiment with Italians is that if someone was born outside of Italy then it is no longer their culture and trying to embrace it or have pride in it is some combo of cringey and/or insulting. It's nice to hear that's not so much the sentiment in this case; when people had their cultural identity so forcibly stripped from them at some point in their lineage, I can only imagine how painful it would be to try and reconnect in what ways you can only to find you are not welcomed.