r/theneighborhoodcbs • u/Jealous-Nail6914 • 2d ago
Just finished the show and I have some thoughts...
i just finished the show, rewatched season 7 (since i didn't remember anything from it) before starting the final season, so both seasons are still pretty fresh in my mind. to start off, the neighborhood is in my top 3 favorite sitcoms, and i actually stumbled upon a random season 1 episode airing on tv back in 2022, loved it, and decided to start watching the whole thing from the pilot.
however, i started noticing more and more things as the seasons went on, and i wasn't really satisfied with the series finale. i wanted to share some of my thoughts on the show and how i felt about the ending.
idk at what point you guys started noticing a decline in quality, but season 4 was the last season i consider peak the neighborhood. i'm not gonna say it feels like a completely different show after that, but idk, i just noticed it wasn't quite at the same level anymore. for example, i feel like they stopped doing some of the things they used to, like making more suggestive jokes (like the one with calvin and tina and the paddle, dave and calvin shaking ass in the painting episode, hell, even just max greenfield shirtless, which isn't exactly the most adult thing in the world, but we haven't gotten that anymore either). the humor also became more pg, and the episodes felt less memorable. i'm not gonna sit here and say the newer episodes are bad because i think that comes down to personal preference, but what i will say is that from season 1 to season 4, the season premieres were always super memorable. season 1 had the pilot, season 2 had the second neighborhood bbq after the johnsons moved in, season 3 had the protest episode, and season 4 had the one where dave finds out he's cousins with calvin.
two other things i've noticed are that the johnsons have basically become the b-plot while the butlers get most of the focus. i love the butlers, but i don't need every single episode to revolve around them. obviously, there are one or two episodes in the more recent seasons that give the johnsons some attention, but i honestly can't think of any off the top of my head rn.
what bothers me the most, though, is how the writing has treated dave in the newer seasons. he's basically become comic relief who says something that only he finds hilarious, embarrasses himself, and then the laugh track kicks in. not a fan of that. that's pretty much all he is now, and i miss when dave was just the nice guy who sometimes didn't realize he was trying too hard, while still being a respected ex-military guy. the way he's been handled in the last few seasons has made me appreciate the version of dave who gave people life lessons and actually helped resolve the conflicts in an episode so much more. the camping episode and the stadium episode are two that immediately come to mind when i think about how much more three-dimensional he used to be.
lastly, i wanna talk about the series finale. let me just get this out of the way: what a bad episode. the worst part is that i clicked on it without realizing it was the finale, so when i realized there were no more episodes left, i was genuinely in shock. like, THIS is how they chose to end the show???
before i get into why i didn't like the ending, i wanna make it clear that i haven't read any reviews or seen anyone else's opinions on it, so i have no idea where the fandom stands on this finale.
the ending is basically an arc that starts a few episodes earlier, with dave wanting them to move back to kalamazoo. honestly, when the finale started and immediately focused on him, i almost got jump-scared because i'm so used to the episodes focusing on the butlers. seeing an episode start with the johnsons dealing with a dilemma without the butlers even being there felt so weird. my brain immediately went, "something is off," before i even realized it was because the johnsons were actually getting the spotlight for once (which is quickly taken away from them).
at that moment, i felt so awful. you guys have no idea. like, the fact that an episode starting with the johnsons having a dilemma to work through and actually being the main focus feels strange to me now is genuinely sad.
i've already accepted that this is just drama created for the final few episodes to set up the johnsons moving away and wrap up the series, but why? why do they need to leave? why is it that when the johnsons finally get the spotlight, it's to set up them moving away and end the show like this? it feels like they realized they needed an emotional moment for the finale, someone suggested, "what if the johnsons moved away?" and they just went with it and wrote the whole thing around that idea. it doesn't feel like they actually sat down together and came up with several different ideas for how to end the show in a satisfying way.