r/learnmath • u/InevitableTell2775 • 1h ago
Updated Russell’s Paradox example?
I was trying to get my head around Russell’s paradox and found the “who shaves the barber” example not very helpful, so I was trying to come up with a more contemporary phrasing that more directly involved sets. Here’s one I came up with:
“Is the girl who’s not like other girls a member of the clique of all the girls who aren’t like other girls?”
This seems to work, because if she is a member, she is like other girls in the clique, so can’t be a member, and if she isn’t a member, then she isn’t like other girls, so is a member. With the added bonus that the paradox applies to all the other girls as well, so clique membership becomes maddeningly arbitrary, just like high school.
Is this an accurate, if whimsical, version of the paradox?