made this chart of all the dolls after i couldn't find another one organized by face mold that i liked. feel free to use & share (credit appreciated)!

edit: can't respond to every single comment, but know i saw & upvoted them all, thank you all so much! i'm so glad others are finding this useful too! <3

Sorry, I've mentioned before that I suffer from face blindness with these face molds, I *think* she's a classic mold(?)

She's blonde with green eyes but I'm not sure which JLY she is even after trying to go through the wiki. Y'all are so good and so fast, so I'm hoping you can help us id his little bff. Thanks in advance. She has medium length wavy blonde hair that we don't think has been cut (it's pulled up in a pony tail and claw clip which is why it's sitting on top of her head).

Hi, I bought this doll probably a year ago, maybe more on ebay. She had on pjs and I had my original Kirsten’s outfit but it was on my original Addy. I just bought the 40th edition release of Addy’s Christmas dress and it arrived. So here I am removing Kirsten’s meet outfit from Addy and then I remove Kirsten’s pjs for the first time since buying her and this is what I see…I feel like I have heard things about white body dolls. So is she extra special?

ETA: I am kinda freaking out right now. I just opened my “The Making Of American Girl” book and it says that “Pleasant signed several hundred dolls for employees and charity auctions…”

ETA 2: I added some additional pictures and context in comments. I got a lot on eBay in August of 2024 of 7 Pleasant Company era dolls for $240. Kirsten was the last one waiting for me to redress because I wanted to put her in my og Kirsten’s outfit and needed an outfit for my og Addy first. The wait was because I was looking for an OG outfit for Addy on ebay but I’m cheap lol so it takes time. I folded on getting an og outfit when I saw the AG rerelease of Addys Christmas outfit. I got it and it came yesterday. So today was my first time ever taking off Kirsten’s clothes. I never took off Samantha or Josefina’s clothes either because they were great on arrival. I just checked them for any extra surprises but alas Kirsten is the only one. Thanks to everyone replying!

GUYSSSSS DO YOU SEE WHO I JUST THRIFTED FOR 8.99 IM FREAKING OUT?

AG needs to release these plush dolls into the other historical characters such as Felicity Kit Kaya Rebecca and Julie

Tag on clothes says 1986 but idk if she's worth anything or if she's too worn and I should just get rid of her, any advice welcome. 🤗

Can anyone tell me if this is rare or how to determine if this doll is worth preserving? I have a signed and numbered 1986 American girl doll? She is not in perfect condition as I played with her as a child. She has her original blue trunk, bed and a few accessories. Debating passing her onto my toddler daughter or if I should save this one and buy her a new one?

does anyone know if they will be actually selling these dolls?! I need Alysa !!! She’s I my favorite skater and I love her hair and smiley piercing !

Hey, A-girlies! (and guys)

Below are my dolls that I currently have along with their name I picked for them! :)

I do have some no-namers, so if you want to help me name them, I think that would fun! :)

And I didn’t even realize until I saw her in person; is she a #4?!

I inherited this from my Aunt and I’m completely overwhelmed. She seems to have been a serious collector and I am not. I like them but this is….a lot. I’ve been using Google lens to identify and sort so I can figure out what goes with what doll. There are 9 dolls and what seems like every outfit and accessory. I took them to give to my nieces but they don’t have room for the sheer amount of stuff.

Do I give it to them? Do I sort out the what might be collectibles and save it? Do I just sell it? (This post is NOT to sell or I’d have put it in the sell thread)

If I keep it, it’s all getting packed away to live in my attic which seems a waste.

If I give it all to my nieces (which I know is the original point of the dolls) all the accessories will be lost or broken.

What do I do????? Thanks in advance!!!

The American girl doll K-pop demon hunters collections presale is sold out online and the company stated they will not be making anymore beyond this. How can I get my hands on one ?

I just bought my very first Josefina doll a few weeks ago and I scored this girl last weekend :)

this is my first ever AG doll gabriella! she was gifted to me to encourage me to be more confident in my dark skin at the time and it absolutely worked. i had an entire youtube channel dedicated to gabby🩷 these screenshots are from my YT channel so please excuse the quality from being 2010 toshiba laptop pixels 😀
i had to move back and forth from my grandmother house as a kid and one day in 2015 my mom pawned her at our local pawn shop, i start college soon and will move out and i really want to try and take gabrielle with me.
is she still being sold? especially if on mercari/ebay/ it doesn’t matter what condition she is. thank you!

found on marketplace for $50! she’s obviously a custom, super interesting to find one in my area. is she worth it? i wonder who she started as…

Getting Kit’s treehouse hat completes this collection for me.

Growing up, I used to think that I had American girl dolls as a kid, but now looking back on the photos, I really am not sure. I think the one in the first photo is a Madame Alexander Dolly and Me doll, but I am not 100% sure. I wasn't in a financially stable household, so I would always get my toys second hand. Anyone know?

Update: Many of you are saying the third one is an American Girl doll, which makes me happy that at least I did have one as a kid and didn't miss out. Sad part is, I think I may have given her away in a donation box years ago... Truly heart breaking! I do have two brand new Our generation dolls, (out of the box) that I may sell eventually so that I can get an American girl doll soon. My "dad" got me them, because AG dolls are so expensive. But two HAS to at least be the same price as getting me one that is used! So, I am a bit upset about that. At first I wasn't as I didn't know the COMPLETELY different quality between the two doll companies, but when I got them out of the boxes and started touching their hair, it was immediately falling out and had lots of bald spots. Turns out Our Generation dolls have the hair rooted into the plastic instead of wigs. The hair is one of the main reasons why I love AG dolls! I am currently satisfied with one of the dolls, just extremely upset I can't play with her hair. Plus, I prefer chubby cheeks. Alas, soon I may be able to find one to my likings.

My niece has been getting into AG and asked me to keep an eye out for them. These girls are pretty and have those ag teeth, but I couldn’t open the bags to actually look at their labels.

I am SO excited I am trying to thrift the American girl collection I never had for my daughter

Is this tm 67? If not, who did I find?

I saw these dolls on Pinterest, and obviously the larger ones are American girls, but the smaller ones are REALLY throwing me off. I am new to the community, so I really don't know much, but as far as I know there are no smaller ag dolls.

Hi - my 8 yr old daughter has asked for a doll for Christmas that looks “just like her” which this one does …. I think her hair is what she would most like to have something similar to
- but I def can’t afford this one!! So I am starting early! Is anyone familiar with any brand of doll that looks or looked a bit like this - I can search for secondhand ones if I have a clue as to how I could get this hair - all advice appreciated xx

3 Months after pre-ordering the adult Felicity Hill House dress, it finally arrived and I'm... very underwhelmed.

My biggest issue is that I'm 75% sure the dress isn't actually made out of cotton. It has the sheen and texture of polyester, at least.

Has anyone else received theirs yet and have the same feeling?