Assalamu alaikum everyone,
I genuinely need some unbiased advice because I've been made to feel like I'm being unreasonable, and at this point I'm questioning my own judgement.
I'm 3 months postpartum, we have two young children, and my son has recently been in hospital, so emotionally I've already had a lot on my plate.
A few months ago, I discovered that my husband had been messaging a non-Muslim woman who he claims is an old family friend. She's someone who regularly has pictures of herself in bikinis or revealing clothes as her WhatsApp profile picture. I know her clothing isn't necessarily relevant to his actions, but it adds to my discomfort given the Islamic boundaries we supposedly uphold in our marriage.
To clarify, she was the one who initially messaged him, but he entertained the conversation and engaged with her rather than shutting it down. At the time, I noticed messages were being deleted. I could see some of her responses but not the full conversations. When I confronted him, he defended the friendship and insisted there was nothing inappropriate happening.
Fast forward to a few weeks ago, she messaged him again saying she was in the city and asking whether he wanted to meet up, adding "no stress if you cant". I initially saw that he hadn't responded, which genuinely made me happy and reassured me.
However, a few days later, I noticed the messages had been deleted again. Her subsequent messages included apologising for not telling him when she was leaving the city, telling him about her upcoming plans, mentioning she'd be back in the city again and saying she hoped he was well.
This confused and upset me because I couldn't understand why she was continuing to message him in this way, particularly apologising for not telling him when she was leaving, if there hadn't been some expectation of meeting or further communication.
I waited a few days before bringing it up because our son had been in hospital and I needed to focus on him.
When I finally confronted my husband, he insisted he had completely ignored her invitation and that her later messages were simply her double-texting without him responding. He says he can't control who messages him and that I'm being unfair for getting upset.
However, he has also admitted that he has responded to her on other occasions simply to be friendly and avoid appearing rude.
When I explained that I found it difficult to believe a woman would repeatedly suggest meeting and continue updating him about her movements if there had been no encouragement or familiarity, he told me I have "little experience in life" and don't understand how people can be.
He essentially believes she's repeatedly reaching out on her own without him encouraging it.
What hurts me is that instead of acknowledging why I might feel uncomfortable, he's become defensive and focused on the fact that I looked at his messages. He says spying is haram, that I don't trust him, and that I'm ungrateful because he does so much for our family.
I understand that looking through someone's messages is a serious issue Islamically, and I'm not claiming I was right to do that. I accept that this is something I need to reflect on as well.
But does that mean my concerns about his communication with another woman and the deleted conversations are automatically invalid?
For context, we are both practising Muslims and have always had an understanding that we don't maintain casual friendships or socialise with the opposite sex. I follow those boundaries myself, which is why this feels particularly hurtful.
I'm not accusing him of physically cheating, and I genuinely don't know whether he responded to her latest messages. But I feel uncomfortable with the previous communication, the repeated deletion of conversations and the way my concerns are being dismissed.
I'm also hurt that he seems more concerned about not appearing rude to another woman than about how this situation is affecting his wife.
I know I'm postpartum and emotionally exhausted, so I'm genuinely trying to understand whether my feelings are reasonable or whether I'm allowing my emotions to cloud my judgement.
My questions are:
Am I wrong for feeling that her repeated messages suggest there may have been some familiarity or encouragement, or could she genuinely be messaging him repeatedly without any response?
Is deleting conversations with a non-mahram woman concerning in this context, or am I reading too much into it?
Islamically, how should a married couple handle situations like this when they've agreed on boundaries regarding the opposite sex?
Am I being unreasonable for wanting my husband to acknowledge my feelings rather than making the entire issue about me checking his phone?
Please be honest, even if you think I'm in the wrong. I'm not looking for people to blindly agree with me. I genuinely want fair advice from an Islamic perspective.
I'm considering showing my husband the responses because I feel like we're going around in circles and neither of us feels understood.
JazakAllah khair.